The gulf between the Premier League and the rest of the EFL
has been well documented, and in recent seasons it has only continued to grow.
However, it seems as though the jump from League 1 to the Championship is
almost in the same ballpark now. I’m going to take a look at the finances and
see how the newly promoted League 1 clubs (Luton, Barnsley and Charlton) could
fair in the battleground that is the English Championship.
Let’s take wages as an example. The average basic wage in the Championship is around £330,000 a year, working out at about £6,300 a week. While this is nowhere near the dizzying heights of Premier League wages, it makes the £70,000 a year average for League 1 look rather small. That works out at £1,346 a week: a significant gulf is starting to emerge. The same can be said for agents’ fees. Last season, League 1 clubs paid a total of £2,611,647 to agents in a bid to sign players. That sounds like a lot money doesn’t it? So, what if I told you Aston Villa alone spent £5,510,180. That’s more than double the League 1 figure. So how can clubs be expected to thrive in the Championship on a League 1 Budget? I’m going to have a look at some past examples to see how clubs have fared making that jump.
In 2015-16, Wigan Athletic won League 1 to secure promotion to the Championship. By the end of the next season, they had regained their League 1 status, finishing 9 points adrift of safety. Then the next season, they were back up again. What does this yoyo tell us about the difficulty clubs have in maintaining themselves at Championship level?
It is obviously not impossible though. Some teams promoted
from League 1 in recent memory include Wolves (Premier League), Bournemouth
(Premier League), Huddersfield (Championship) and Brighton (Premier League). So
it can be done. The newly promoted teams will face a level of competition and
finances that they are not used to, so how will they get on?
Luton’s story has been quite remarkable. From the infamous -30 points season of 08/09, to near bankruptcy and then to 3 promotions in 6 years (going up from League 2 and League 1 in successive campaigns). They came into League 1 with a decent budget, but there were limited expectations. The budget and spending placed them around the playoffs, so to go on and win the league was a massive achievement. They are a prime example of how important good ownership is to a football club, and so my predicted finish for The Hatters in the Championship is 15th.
Barnsley have Championship experience as recently as
2017-18, being relegated after some ownership problems led to the selling of
80% of the club and the sacking of Assistant Manager Tommy Wright. New
ownership gave the club momentum, as did the appointing of manager Daniel
Stendel. Given the calibre of player that Barnsley have (some were retained
from the Championship), my prediction for the Tykes is 13th.
Charlton’s promotion was thanks to a unified group of players and management, and in spite of their owners. Protests continue against the owners off the pitch, but on it they were one of the best footballing sides in the league. The troubles with the owners may well make it difficult to make quality signings and investments, so a lot of trust will have to be put in the players that got them into the Championships to keep them there. My predicted finish for the Addicks is 18th.